rachelmanija asked me for an explanation of the pseuicide situation. I've seen a lot of people on Tumblr who are also confused, so I'm posting an edited version of my response to her.

(Note that I wrote this around midnight on New Years - a good way to celebrate! - and some of the credulity has died down since then.)

So. A bunch of Tumblr users recently pretended to attempt suicide due to "anonymous hate." They then either "miraculously recovered" or revealed that their "account was hacked."

People affected by this plague of undeath:

* cwinchster2000
* kingfrerin/Anthea/brvnner
* d—e—s—t—i—e—l
* randomawkwardawesome
* queen-of-the-rising-demons
* paintedcastiel/insecurecharlie
* simormonroe + wearejustalike
* whiskeyjensen
* chesnutmisha
* spnpie1967/anonxdlol (1, 2, 3, 4, 5. Other sources: 6, 7)
* mopeters1954
* rainbowcas (didn't go through with the “death,” but has the funniest implausible narrative and was clearly the inspiration for some of the others)
* someone who plagiarized Leelah Alcorn's suicide note in an apparent attempt to equate the "harassment of fandom" to transmisogyny, which I'm not linking because it crosses a line for me.


These are all members of the Supernatural fandom. What we're seeing here is basically a case of mass hysteria caused by a cascade of people

1) faking anonymous hate mail against themselves, generally mentioning personal vulnerabilities and urging them to commit suicide in very specific ways,
2) after responding to their enemies for a while to build up the tension, faking suicide due to their intense distress over the anonymous hate,
3) successfully acquiring the attention and followers they wanted during this period and the necessary hospital drama narrated by a nonexistent person,
4) miraculously being resuscitated and/or claiming to have been "hacked" by bad guys, and
5) thus inspiring others to imitate the project.

Because people actually are buying the hacker story. It's a Christmas miracle.

Most of the "anonymous hate" is very, very obviously from the people to whom it was addressed. Or, it should be obvious! But a lot of the SPN fandom on Tumblr doesn't recognize these tactics! They're too young and are disengaged with the fandom lore, or else they're getting it from Andy fucking Blake of all people. (He's trying to "reach out" to the kids who committed pseuecide right now.)

Read more... )

(Here is a blog where I'm saving my "favorite" posts from the tags, and here is the first post I made about the situation.)
I know I need to stop looking at the #affectedbyhate tag. And I'm going to! Soon!

But there have been at least eight distinct confirmed pseuecides. In five days. It's been the asshole World Series, I think the one who sprained her nose won?

Under the cut are sloppy summaries of each fake death I'm aware of, with excerpts. I put some of this on FFA earlier while this vital archival work was still in progress.

cwinchster2000 )

kingfrerin/Anthea/brvnner )

d—e—s—t—i—e—l )

randomawkwardawesome )

queen-of-the-rising-demons )

paintedcastiel/insecurecharlie )

simormonroe + wearejustalike )

whiskeyjensen )

BONUS - rainbowcas )
You can turn this sea of manipulative fictions into something truly special.

The fictional Vince who is leading the fictional raids is now, I guess, being conflated with the fictional Israeli from the ARG's early mythology, and has ordered his fictional 4chan/8chan troops to attack Muslim blogs.

Dec. 30th, 2014 05:24 pm
I have created a blog to document the high points of the exciting ARG known as #affectedbyhate.

Warning for people using self-harm and suicide as RPG status ailments.

Dec. 29th, 2014 02:57 pm
(Last night I saved over 200 fucking pages of the affectedbyhate tag, for Science Analysis, by Scientists. I have a problem.

CG: THEY'RE REALLY INTRIGUING SOCIOLOGICALLY.
CG: INCREDIBLY COMPLEX, SOPHISTICATED STORIES, YOU WOULDN'T GET IT.)
The affectedbyhate tag is the most morbidly-fascinating thing. Most of the people posting in it are plainly not in any actual emotional distress - or, no more so than when they’re watching a moderately affecting episode of their TV show, anyway. It’s become a role-playing game with clearly-defined parameters. There are

* healing abilities (sending supportive asks)

* buffs (gained occasionally as a bonus from supportive asks or doing online anxiety-relieving tasks from those lists)

* “Safe Houses” (blogs open to requests for supportive asks - basically healing fountains?)

* missions/quests (going on Omegle to “collect information” or try to “save” imaginary people from self-harming or committing suicide)

* mobs (anon hate mail people send themselves or their friends/acquaintances, which you have to “defeat” by responding to as if it actually bothers you but you’re being brave)

* negative status effects (…the ostensible desire to self-harm. Uh.)

* loss of HP (…ostensible actual self-harm and suicide attempts.)

* bosses (hackers who “force” people to commit pseuicide)

A dreadful mass hysteria-themed ARG has generated spontaneously, as mice do in dirty corners.

…So, yeah, this is all pretty fucked-up! Insincere performative suffering of the sort on display in the tag sets a standard which people who are actually suffering cannot ordinarily meet, both because they do not know the genre rules - the genre rules now on in effect are quite strict - and because they do not have the energy to put on a little show.

(See also: people who are so emotionally affected by the constructed narratives of cancer fakers that they don’t care about actual cancer patients. The actual cancer patients are not telling the story right. There need to be, like, photos of your bald head while you wanly hug a pink stuffed bear with “Susan G. Komen” embroidered on there! Come on, step up your game!)

Also, depressed kids who do not realize that this shit is constructed might be influenced by the contrived air of despair and apparent normalization of self-harm and suicide attempts to actually hurt themselves.

While most of the people actively posting in the tag seem to be in on the game, not everyone who’s seeing these posts is also seeing their bizarre context - they’re just seeing their friends apparently melting down in despair.

December 2018

S M T W T F S
      1
2345 678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
3031     

Style Credit

Syndicate

RSS Atom
Page generated Jan. 20th, 2026 05:10 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags

Most Popular Tags

Creative Commons



The contents of this blog and all comments I make are licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-Share Alike License. I hope that name is long enough. I could add some stuff. It could also be a Bring Me A Sandwich License.

If you desire to thank me for the pretend internet magnanimity I show by sharing my important and serious thoughts with you, I accept pretend internet dollars (Bitcoins): 19BqFnAHNpSq8N2A1pafEGSqLv4B6ScstB